Homemade Eggnog Recipe

This homemade eggnog recipe is the best eggnog you will ever taste. It's thick and creamy with hints of nutmeg, cinnamon and vanilla. It's easy to make and so delicious that you'll never settle for store-bought again!

This post is sponsored by Walmart. All recipes, photos and opinions are my own.

Every year as the weather changes and the holidays draw near, the first wintery treat that my family asks for is eggnog.

Eggnog is a must-have to enjoy while we decorate our Christmas tree (along with homemade hot chocolate, and peppermint hot chocolate)!

However, I usually don't prefer to buy store-bought eggnog because of the ingredient list. So I created this homemade eggnog recipe. It's thick and creamy with hints of nutmeg, cinnamon and vanilla. Plus, it's easy to make with a handful of ingredients.

Making homemade eggnog ensures you can use organic ingredients and skip the food dyes and artificial flavors. And organic doesn't have to mean pricey - I regularly cook and bake with the organic Great Value products from Walmart (like organic cinnamon, organic nutmeg, etc.) and love them for both the quality and price.

Egg Nog: Ingredients & Substitutions

This recipe is so delicious that I don't recommend making substitutions. However, if you must, here are a few suggestions.

This is true about all recipes, but especially true for this eggnog recipe - the quality of the ingredients you choose really matters and will make an impact on the final product. I suggest heading to Walmart to find budget-friendly organic ingredients to make this eggnog recipe.

• Egg yolks. Use large, organic eggs for the best results!
• Granulated sugar. Regular white granulated sugar and organic cane sugar both work well in this recipe.
• Heavy cream/whole milk. This eggnog recipe calls for 3 cups of liquid dairy. I always make it with 2 cups heavy cream and 1 cup whole milk. You can change the ratio (e.g. 2 cups whole milk, 1 cup cream), or use lower-fat products like half and half or 2% milk but you do so at the risk of a less-creamy final product.
• Ground Nutmeg. You can substitute an equal amount of freshly ground nutmeg if you prefer. I use store-bought organic nutmeg with the best results.
• Ground Cinnamon. Using a high-quality organic cinnamon will yield the best results.
• Sea salt. A pinch of sea salt really makes this recipe extra delicious. You can omit it, if you prefer.
• Pure vanilla extract. Be sure to use the real thing, not imitation. You can substitute vanilla bean paste or the seeds of one vanilla bean.

Shop tools & ingredients for homemade eggnog:

How to make Eggnog

This homemade eggnog recipe comes together in 10 minutes and is fairly simple to make. We'll walk through how to make eggnog step-by-step and don't forget to watch the video!

To being, beat the eggs and sugar together with a handheld mixer (or vigorously with a whisk by hand), until, thick and light (about 1 minute).

The mixture will thicken as you set it aside and continue making the rest of the recipe.

Next, heat the whole milk, cinnamon, nutmeg, and sea salt in a medium saucepan until the mixture is warm and just barely begins to bubble around the edges, whisking constantly.

Once the mixture is warm, temper the eggs by slowly adding the warm milk to the beaten eggs as you whisk vigorously.

Note: the egg mixture will be thick upon the first addition of milk. As you whisk in more milk it will thin out.

Next, pour the tempered egg/milk mixture back into the saucepan and cook until it starts to thicken but does not boil (160 degrees F on an instant read thermometer), whisking often. (it will lightly coat the back of a spatula).

Then, place the heavy cream into a bowl with a fine mesh strainer on top of the bowl.

Strain the egg mixture into the heavy cream. Discard the residue that is left on the strainer.

Then, stir in the vanilla extract until it's just incorporated.

Chill the eggnog

Next, transfer the homemade eggnog to a glass jar with a lid (a large, 1 quart jar) or put it in a glass container with a lid to chill for at least 4 hours.

Serve

This eggnog recipe is best served cold with some homemade whipped cream and an extra sprinkle of nutmeg.

We found these drinking glasses at Walmart that are prefect for serving! They are thick and high-quality and just the right size for a serving of rich homemade eggnog.

You could also serve this eggnog recipe in glass mugs and tie cute mini ornaments on the handles to mark whose glass is whose (as well as adding some holiday flair). I love these cute little pinecone mini ornaments and these reindeers!

How to store eggnog

Store leftover eggnog in a glass jar with a lid in the refrigerator for up to 5 days.

To freeze

If you'd like, you can freeze this eggnog recipe in ice cube trays and use it to make some delicious eggnog iced coffee! Yum! Or you can freeze it in larger portions in a silicone storage container. Reheat slowly on the stovetop or in the microwave.

Recipe FAQs

If you make and love our recipes, it would mean so much to me if you would leave a comment and rating! And don't forget to follow along with us on Instagram, Pinterest, Facebook, and Youtube - be sure to tag @joyfoodsunshine and use the hashtag #joyfoodsunshine so we can your creations!

This post contains affiliate links, which means that if you purchase a product through a link you clicked on here, I receive a portion of the sale. Thank you for supporting JoyFoodSunshine!